Insurance Brokers in Milwaukee, WI

Browse 92 insurance brokers in Milwaukee, Wisconsin.

Adams Insurance Service Inc

MilwaukeeWI
General Insurance Broker
★★★★★5(6)
(414) 257-2070
View Details →

Allrisk Financial srvcs inc DBA Savemore Insurance Agency

MilwaukeeWI
General Insurance Broker
★★★★★5(4)
(414) 461-9759
View Details →

Allstate

MilwaukeeWI
General Insurance Broker
★★★★★5(1)
View Details →

American Family Insurance - Dennis James

MilwaukeeWI
General Insurance Broker
★★★★★5(2)
(414) 259-0040
View Details →

APECS Insurance Agency

MilwaukeeWI
General Insurance Broker
★★★★★5(369)
(414) 332-1152
View Details →

Brew City Insurance

MilwaukeeWI
General Insurance Broker
★★★★★5(141)
(414) 762-6600
View Details →

Comprehensive Insurance WI

MilwaukeeWI
General Insurance Broker
★★★★★5(10)
(414) 236-7654
View Details →

Daniel Monahan Insurance: Transition Health Benefits

MilwaukeeWI
General Insurance Broker
★★★★★5(270)
(414) 426-8256
View Details →

FHK Insurance

MilwaukeeWI
General Insurance Broker
★★★★★5(357)
(414) 228-7555
View Details →

Fortitude Public Adjusters

MilwaukeeWI
General Insurance Broker
★★★★★5(89)
(844) 383-3473
View Details →

Gramoll & Associates Inc American Family Insurance

MilwaukeeWI
General Insurance Broker
★★★★★5(800)
(414) 332-0838
View Details →

Holter Agency: Gardiner Steven

MilwaukeeWI
General Insurance Broker
★★★★★5(1)
(414) 615-1804
View Details →

Insurance Company WI

MilwaukeeWI
General Insurance Broker
★★★★★5(8)
(414) 204-7303
View Details →

Logan Kassner - Insurance Advising & Risk Management

MilwaukeeWI
General Insurance Broker
★★★★★5(2)
(920) 255-4541
View Details →

Martinez Powless & Associates, LLC American Family Insurance

MilwaukeeWI
General Insurance Broker
★★★★★5(20)
(414) 373-7997
View Details →

Matthew J. Holbrook - COUNTRY Financial Representative

MilwaukeeWI
General Insurance Broker
★★★★★5(23)
(414) 332-2137
View Details →

Midwest Insurance Group

MilwaukeeWI
General Insurance Broker
★★★★★5(231)
(262) 646-5777
View Details →

Milz Health Group

MilwaukeeWI
General Insurance Broker
★★★★★5(97)
(262) 299-4904
View Details →

MKE Benefits

MilwaukeeWI
General Insurance Broker
★★★★★5(6)
(414) 368-0900
View Details →

Munoz Insurance Agency LLC

MilwaukeeWI
General Insurance Broker
★★★★★5(12)
(414) 435-3505
View Details →

Mutual Insurance Agency WI

MilwaukeeWI
General Insurance Broker
★★★★★5(10)
(414) 206-3025
View Details →

Pioneer Insurance Co

MilwaukeeWI
General Insurance Broker
★★★★★5(8)
(262) 299-5865
View Details →

Schueller Harrington & Associates: Halloran Jill

MilwaukeeWI
General Insurance Broker
★★★★★5(3)
(414) 765-2300
View Details →

Star Insurance Company of WI

MilwaukeeWI
General Insurance Broker
★★★★★5(7)
(414) 209-5117
View Details →

The Auto Insurance Tribe

MilwaukeeWI
General Insurance Broker
★★★★★5(6)
(214) 216-4281
View Details →

Vizance

MilwaukeeWI
General Insurance Broker
★★★★★5(41)
(262) 367-8611
View Details →

1201 Insurance Services, Inc.

MilwaukeeWI
General Insurance Broker
★★★★★5(17)
(414) 409-1263
View Details →

American One Insurance Agency, LLC

MilwaukeeWI
General Insurance Broker
★★★★★4.9(24)
(414) 539-4036
View Details →

Insurance Center of Milwaukee

MilwaukeeWI
General Insurance Broker
★★★★★4.9(65)
(414) 744-6614
View Details →

J. Setum Agency, Inc. American Family Insurance

MilwaukeeWI
General Insurance Broker
★★★★★4.9(93)
(414) 769-0701
View Details →

Laura Ashley - State Farm Insurance Agent

MilwaukeeWI
General Insurance Broker
★★★★★4.9(210)
(414) 453-8672
View Details →

Philleo Agency Insurance

MilwaukeeWI
General Insurance Broker
★★★★★4.9(1209)
(262) 432-4200
View Details →

Steinfeld Ins. Agency, LLC dba Cream City Insurance

MilwaukeeWI
General Insurance Broker
★★★★★4.9(176)
(262) 649-2063
View Details →

Capital Insurance of Wi

MilwaukeeWI
General Insurance Broker
★★★★★4.8(16)
(262) 781-8080
View Details →

Dave Kelley: Allstate Insurance

MilwaukeeWI
General Insurance Broker
★★★★★4.8(79)
(414) 988-5271
View Details →

Frank Car Insurance

MilwaukeeWI
General Insurance Broker
★★★★★4.8(44)
View Details →

Luepke Insurance Agency

MilwaukeeWI
General Insurance Broker
★★★★★4.8(25)
(414) 482-1040
View Details →

Martin Manley American Family Insurance

MilwaukeeWI
General Insurance Broker
★★★★★4.8(48)
(414) 546-3338
View Details →

Multiline Insurance Agency

MilwaukeeWI
General Insurance Broker
★★★★★4.8(17)
(414) 963-9412
View Details →

Procter Insurance Agency

MilwaukeeWI
General Insurance Broker
★★★★★4.8(85)
(414) 762-8900
View Details →

R&R Insurance Services, Inc.

MilwaukeeWI
General Insurance Broker
★★★★★4.8(167)
(262) 574-7000
View Details →

Rembert Financial Services, LLC

MilwaukeeWI
General Insurance Broker
★★★★★4.8(5)
(414) 441-5997
View Details →

Riley Kubatzke Agency, INC. American Family Insurance

MilwaukeeWI
General Insurance Broker
★★★★★4.8(57)
(414) 747-0990
View Details →

Tamer Insurance Agency LLC

MilwaukeeWI
General Insurance Broker
★★★★★4.8(17)
(414) 476-0700
View Details →

Wisconsin Health Insurance Advocate, LLC

MilwaukeeWI
General Insurance Broker
★★★★★4.8(25)
(414) 797-3408
View Details →

Andrew J. McCabe: Allstate Insurance

MilwaukeeWI
General Insurance Broker
★★★★★4.7(525)
(414) 895-5052
View Details →

B & J Insurance Agency, Inc.

MilwaukeeWI
General Insurance Broker
★★★★★4.7(100)
(414) 461-4120
View Details →

Billy Brown Insurance

MilwaukeeWI
General Insurance Broker
★★★★★4.7(60)
(262) 646-8252
View Details →

Bob Vitt - State Farm Insurance Agent

MilwaukeeWI
General Insurance Broker
★★★★★4.7(127)
(414) 276-3446
View Details →

Bridge Insurance Agency

MilwaukeeWI
General Insurance Broker
★★★★★4.7(58)
(414) 282-2021
View Details →

Freeway Insurance

MilwaukeeWI
General Insurance Broker
★★★★★4.7(352)
(414) 501-3055
View Details →

Marchan Agency, LLC American Family Insurance

MilwaukeeWI
General Insurance Broker
★★★★★4.7(23)
(414) 744-2192
View Details →

Sean Aldrich - State Farm Insurance Agent

MilwaukeeWI
General Insurance Broker
★★★★★4.7(84)
(414) 483-3300
View Details →

See Insurance Agency LLC

MilwaukeeWI
General Insurance Broker
★★★★★4.7(17)
(414) 355-5433
View Details →

Barker & Associates, Inc. American Family Insurance

MilwaukeeWI
General Insurance Broker
★★★★★4.6(53)
(414) 332-8350
View Details →

Brown & Brown Milwaukee, formerly Hays Companies

MilwaukeeWI
General Insurance Broker
★★★★★4.6(5)
(414) 443-0000
View Details →

Frank Medina Insurance

MilwaukeeWI
General Insurance Broker
★★★★★4.6(19)
(414) 877-0777
View Details →

Schwade Insurance Agency Inc

MilwaukeeWI
General Insurance Broker
★★★★★4.6(33)
(414) 462-5000
View Details →

Sherry Watson American Family Insurance

MilwaukeeWI
General Insurance Broker
★★★★★4.6(59)
(414) 277-7772
View Details →

The Insurance Office

MilwaukeeWI
General Insurance Broker
★★★★★4.6(101)
(414) 302-0101
View Details →

Lamar Dismuke American Family Insurance

MilwaukeeWI
General Insurance Broker
★★★★★4.5(68)
(414) 527-1925
View Details →

Nova Insurance LLC

MilwaukeeWI
General Insurance Broker
★★★★★4.5(21)
(414) 212-8700
View Details →

Reed Street Insurance

MilwaukeeWI
General Insurance Broker
★★★★★4.5(23)
(414) 277-0414
View Details →

Trustant Insurance Agency

MilwaukeeWI
General Insurance Broker
★★★★★4.5(11)
(414) 771-4700
View Details →

Vital Insurance Services

MilwaukeeWI
General Insurance Broker
★★★★★4.5(27)
(414) 810-3010
View Details →

Cyndy Johnson: Allstate Insurance

MilwaukeeWI
General Insurance Broker
★★★★☆4.4(59)
(414) 445-2558
View Details →

Diana Kostal - State Farm Insurance Agent

MilwaukeeWI
General Insurance Broker
★★★★☆4.4(50)
(414) 964-8680
View Details →

Santiago Insurance Agency LLC

MilwaukeeWI
General Insurance Broker
★★★★☆4.4(42)
(414) 727-8284
View Details →

Cheap Car Insurance Milwaukee

MilwaukeeWI
General Insurance Broker
★★★★☆4.3(6)
(414) 246-9411
View Details →

Den-Wu SR22 Insurance Agency Wisconsin

MilwaukeeWI
General Insurance Broker
★★★★☆4.3(6)
(262) 310-7433
View Details →

Kirchen Insurance

MilwaukeeWI
General Insurance Broker
★★★★☆4.3(16)
(414) 352-5750
View Details →

Schueller Harrington & Associates

MilwaukeeWI
General Insurance Broker
★★★★☆4.3(6)
(414) 765-2300
View Details →

Wesley Insurance

MilwaukeeWI
General Insurance Broker
★★★★☆4.3(22)
(414) 873-4500
View Details →

Northwestern Mutual

MilwaukeeWI
General Insurance Broker
★★★★☆4.2(21)
(414) 271-3242
View Details →

Reilly Insurance Services

MilwaukeeWI
General Insurance Broker
★★★★☆4.2(27)
(414) 482-2473
View Details →

Alianza Insurance Services LLC

MilwaukeeWI
General Insurance Broker
★★★★☆4(12)
(414) 928-8673
View Details →

American Advantage Insurance Group

MilwaukeeWI
General Insurance Broker
★★★★☆4(4)
(414) 225-6240
View Details →

Badger Mutual Insurance Company

MilwaukeeWI
General Insurance Broker
★★★★☆4(351)
(800) 837-7833
View Details →

Latus Insurance

MilwaukeeWI
General Insurance Broker
★★★★☆4(42)
(414) 321-2700
View Details →

Wisconsin Insurance Plan

MilwaukeeWI
General Insurance Broker
★★★★☆4(7)
(414) 291-5353
View Details →

Lor Insurance Services Llc

MilwaukeeWI
General Insurance Broker
★★★★☆3.9(15)
(414) 321-5850
View Details →

Ken Toureene Agency, Inc. American Family Insurance

MilwaukeeWI
General Insurance Broker
★★★★☆3.8(4)
(414) 259-1951
View Details →

Alex Ferreira: Allstate Insurance

MilwaukeeWI
General Insurance Broker
★★★★☆3.5(82)
(414) 672-2000
View Details →

Independent Care Health Plan (iCare)

MilwaukeeWI
General Insurance Broker
★★★★☆3.5(32)
(800) 777-4376
View Details →

M3 Insurance

MilwaukeeWI
General Insurance Broker
★★★☆☆3.4(5)
(262) 524-1038
View Details →

Brennan Insurance Agency

MilwaukeeWI
General Insurance Broker
★★★☆☆3.3(7)
(414) 271-7517
View Details →

Progressive Insurance - Claims Office

MilwaukeeWI
General Insurance Broker
★★☆☆☆2.3(74)
(800) 776-4737
View Details →

Progressive Car Insurance

MilwaukeeWI
General Insurance Broker
★★☆☆☆2.2(10)
(414) 409-5705
View Details →

Erie Insurance: Wisconsin Office

MilwaukeeWI
General Insurance Broker
★★☆☆☆1.8(32)
(262) 798-1941
View Details →

Molina Healthcare of Wisconsin

MilwaukeeWI
General Insurance Broker
★☆☆☆☆1.4(123)
(888) 999-2404
View Details →

Hanover Insurance Co

MilwaukeeWI
General Insurance Broker
★☆☆☆☆1(3)
(414) 489-2645
View Details →

B&J Insurance Agency

MilwaukeeWI
General Insurance Broker
(414) 461-4120
View Details →

Frequently Asked Questions

How do I choose an insurance broker in Milwaukee?

A broker works for YOU — they shop multiple insurance companies to find the best coverage and price. An agent works for ONE insurance company and can only sell that company's products. Brokers can compare 10-20 insurers at once, saving you time and usually money. Every broker listed on this Milwaukee, Wisconsin page is an independent business — compare the coverage types each one handles, then contact two or three and ask what they would shop on your behalf.

Does using a broker in Milwaukee cost more than buying direct?

No — brokers are paid by the insurance companies through commissions, not by you. The price you pay for insurance is the same whether you go through a broker or directly to the insurer. But brokers often find better rates because they can compare multiple companies.

What should I have ready before I call a Milwaukee broker?

Use a broker when: you're buying a home, getting your first car insurance, starting a business, your renewal went up significantly, you've had claims and need help finding coverage, or you simply want someone to shop the market for you. Have the details of whatever prompted the call ready — the property, the vehicle, or the business you need covered — plus your current policy and renewal notice if you have one. At least annually at renewal time. Also review whenever you: buy or sell a home, get a new vehicle, start a business, get married or divorced, have children, or make major purchases. Your broker should proactively reach out at renewal to review your coverage.